The Fact News Service
Chandigarh, October 21
Bir Devinder Singh, former Deputy Speaker, Punjab Vidhan Sabha slammed Punjab Chief Minister Bhagwant Mann for releasing correspondence between him and Governor Banwarilal Purohit in media in advance.
Singh said that CM Mann has violated the ‘Oath of Secrecy.
“If there is persistent scrimmage and procrastination between the two constitutional authorities of the State; the vital interests of the State suffers and by implication people of the State are put to needless agony. The Governor of the State and the Chief Minister, both are constitutional authorities and their role and jurisdiction is also well-defined, under the Constitution of India.The Governor of Punjab Mr. Banwarilal Purohit and the Chief Minister of Punjab Mr. Bhagwant Mann are seemingly at logger head for quite some time, may be lack of proper coordination and understanding between these two, most important constitutional offices. The role and the overriding authority of the Governor is clearly defined and thoroughly articulated under Article 167 and 168 of the constitution. Schedule 3 of the Indian Constitution deals with the Oaths or Affirmations and also an oath of Secrecy for Ministers of the States that includes the Chief Minister of the State. The Oath of Secrecy that was administered to Mr. Bagwant Mann by the Governor Mr. Banwarilal Purohit in a stipulated format of the oath form says : “ I Bhagwant Mann do swear in the name of God that I will not directly or indirectly communicate or reveal to any person or persons any matter which shall be brought under my consideration or shall become known to me as a the Chief Minister for the State of Punjab except as may be required for the due discharge of my duties as Chief Minister”,” Bir Devinder noted.
“Now in the current tug of war between the Governor and the Chief Minister over the issue of appointment of Dr. Satbir Singh Gosal as the Vice Chancellor of The Punjab Agriculture University, Ludhiana, rather than sorting out the issue amicably with Governor of the State, The Chief Minister Mr. Bhagwant Mann has committed another wrong and further vexed the tangle and complicated the issue beyond comprehension. The Punjab Raj Bhawan in the milieu of the controversy, over two unidentical letters, purported to have written by the CM, has the upper hand; because the one letter written in English was sent to the Governor and the other one circulated to the media in advance, was written in Punjabi and was also posted on the Twitter of the Chief Minister. Surprisingly transcript of both the letters (English and Punjabi) materially differs from each other in conveying entirely different connotation and nuance, one written in English is seemingly quite mild and modest but the other in Punjabi is more contemptuous in construct and the tone and tenor of its panorama is blatantly arrogant and also in the bad taste,” he said.
“I am of the considered view that the classified communication between Chief Minster and the Governor of the State over a contentious issue, should have been handled more carefully by the office of the Chief Minister by marking it as ‘Strictly Confidential’ under the ‘communiqué protocol’ and should not have released to the media, at all. The Chief Minister’s office must know that Twitter is not the ‘Secretly notified letter Box of the Governor’ and the Governor is right in his ‘Constitutional Dignity’ if he takes serious view of such a misdemeanor of debased equilibrium of protocol consciousness in the CMO, that apparently lacks sagaciousness and delicate political acumen. Such a ‘conspicuously sensitive correspondence’ with the Governor, containing divergent views, if released to the press puerilely, it certainly amounts to a deliberate attempt to disparage the dignity of the Constitutional Head of the State i.e. The Governor of Punjab and the Chief Minister Bhagwant Mann could squarely be blamed and charged for the violation of the Oath of Secrecy, administered to him while assuming office of Chief Minister by the Governor Banwarilal Purohit. In this context, its pertinent to mention here that such a mishandling of classified correspondence between the Governor and the Chief Minister can incur criminal penalties and the violation of the Oath of Secrecy administered to the Chief Minister; entails the termination of the tenure of the office and most importantly this power can be exercised by the appointing authority under the constitution. Therefore I would suggest the Chief Minister Punjab, who is much younger to me in age, that he should handle his desk very carefully and sort out issues with the Governor as early as possible and also bring competent officers in his office, helpful to smoothen the system of stately Governance and all such officers responsible for the serious lapses and creating unnecessary ruckus in the corridor of powers almost every day must be shown the door forthwith,” former Deputy Speaker added.