SC Rebukes BJP Leader: “Not Our Job, Go to Centre Govt”
New Delhi: February 24, 2026
CJI Justice Surya Kant-led bench sternly rebuked BJP leader Ashwini Upadhyay during West Bengal voter list SIR hearing. Court clarified fake Aadhaar probe is executive (govt) responsibility, not judiciary.
Upadhyay claimed “industrial-scale” fake Aadhaars for Rohingyas in WB, sought Aadhaar verification clarification in SIR.
Not Investigation Agency
CJI: Serious issue needs detailed probe/policy decision—”Court not suitable forum.” Approach Centre for law changes.
Aadhaar ≠ Citizenship
Justice Joimalya Bagchi: Aadhaar is ID document only—”No question of citizenship determination via Aadhaar.” Regulate fraud via govt.
Per Sept 2025 orders:
Representation of People Act 1950 Section 23(4) accepts Aadhaar as 12th ID proof.
Officers can demand additional verification.
Petitioner advised approach Union govt. Jharkhand/Odisha judges can monitor WB SIR.